Formal Letter
Domestic Violence Brain Injury and Strangulation in Hawai‘i
A request for federal and state action to protect survivors, strengthen prosecution standards, and recognize invisible neurological injuries.
To:
President Donald J. Trump
U.S. Attorney General Todd Blanche
Governor Josh Green, M.D.
From:
Brian Alston
Domestic Violence Case Manager, Hawai‘i
Subject: Federal and State Action on Domestic Violence-Related Brain Injury and Strangulation
My name is Brian, and I work directly with survivors of domestic violence across Hawai‘i. I am witnessing violence so severe, so invisible, and so consistently minimized that I no longer believe the women involved will survive without decisive federal and state intervention.
Across our islands, especially on Kaua‘i, perpetrators are using MMA-style chokeholds, closed-fist blows to the head, and suffocation techniques that knock women unconscious. These assaults often leave no visible injuries, yet they cause traumatic and anoxic brain injuries, impairing memory, judgment, emotional regulation, and the ability to escape. These are not domestic disputes. They are attempted homicides occurring inside Hawai‘i homes.
The Kaua‘i Case: Travis
One survivor has been repeatedly punched in the head, targeted blows meant to avoid bruising. Each time she returns to shelter, her cognitive symptoms worsen. Despite the severity of these assaults, Travis is being considered for probation for violence medically consistent with attempted murder. I have watched her struggle to think clearly, to parent, and to stay alive. I do not believe she will survive another attack without immediate legal intervention.
The Hotline Case: Suffocation as Control
Weeks ago, I answered a hotline call from a woman whose boyfriend used his arms to choke her unconscious. She told me: “Every time I woke up, he would put me back to sleep.” He did this to keep her from leaving after repeatedly raping her. There were no marks on her neck, but her brain was injured every single time. This is oxygen deprivation and repeated neurological damage, yet it is routinely treated as a low-level offense.
The Pattern Across Hawai‘i
- Head strikes where bruises will not show.
- Chokeholds mimicking MMA techniques.
- Suffocation until unconsciousness.
- Survivors waking up disoriented and neurologically impaired.
- Police documenting no visible injuries.
- Severe assaults and even arson going uncharged.
- Low-level charges and probation.
- Perpetrators escalating.
- Survivors becoming trapped psychologically, neurologically, and physically.
This violence destroys autonomy at the neurological level and makes escape nearly impossible. When the system fails to hold men accountable, they continue.
Men do not beat women. They protect them. We must train our sons and protect our daughters. Men change when accountability is immediate and uncompromising.
The Medical Reality
- Brain cells begin dying after 4 to 6 minutes without oxygen.
- 50% of strangulation victims show no visible injuries.
- Symptoms may appear hours or days later.
- Loss of consciousness is not required for brain injury.
- Repeated head trauma causes cumulative neurological damage.
- Strangulation is a leading predictor of future homicide.
These are lethal-level attacks, not minor assaults.
The Legal Reality in Hawai‘i
- Each island handles domestic violence differently.
- No statewide standard exists for prosecuting strangulation or head trauma.
- Medical evaluation is rarely required.
- TBI screening is almost nonexistent.
- Perpetrators who knock women unconscious often receive probation.
- Repeat offenders escalate without consequence.
This is how women die.
A Unified Call for Federal and State Action
Hawai‘i cannot fix this alone. We need federal leadership, federal standards, and federal pressure.
Proposal: Federal-State Initiative on DV-Related Brain Injury and Strangulation
- Mandatory felony charges for repeated head blows, strangulation, suffocation, loss of consciousness, or suspected brain injury.
- Required medical evaluation for head trauma, strangulation, oxygen deprivation, and cognitive impairment.
- Statewide Hawai‘i domestic violence prosecution standards for charging, medical protocols, documentation, and lethality assessments.
- Federal review of Hawai‘i’s domestic violence sentencing, probation decisions, and systemic failures.
- Training for law enforcement, prosecutors, and judges on TBI, strangulation lethality, invisible injuries, and cognitive impairment.
- Minimum 10-year sentencing for repeated head injury or strangulation.
- Cultural leadership: Men do not beat or rape women. They protect them. We must train our sons and protect our daughters.
Closing
Women in Hawai‘i are losing consciousness in their own homes. Their memories fade, their personalities change, and their injuries go unrecognized while perpetrators walk free. I have watched the system fail them. I do not believe the women I have described, especially the survivor in the Kaua‘i case, will live without decisive intervention.
Please act. Please lead. Please help us protect Hawai‘i’s daughters and correct Hawai‘i’s sons. Please help us stop violence that is invisible, lethal, and escalating.
Men change when accountability is immediate and uncompromising. Lives change when leaders act.
Respectfully,
Brian Alston
Domestic Violence Case Manager
Hawai‘i (agency not listed)